OCE vs. Violating Amateurism: Knowing the Difference

Link to NAIA Bylaws – Season of Competition
Link to NAIA Bylaws Loss of Amateurism

When evaluating a student’s competition history, it’s important to understand whether their participation falls under the Outside Competitive Experience (OCE) rule or if it involves a violation of amateur status. While both can result in seasons of competition being charged, they stem from two distinct areas of NAIA legislation.

Outside Competitive Experience (OCE): Competing With or Against Professionals

OCE focuses on the level of competition, not the student’s amateur standing.
If a student competes with or against professional or semi-professional teams or athletes, that experience is evaluated under the OCE rule (Article V, Section B, Item 20b).

Key Points:

  • Competing with or against professional/semi-professional participants is considered professional-level competition.
  • The student will be charged one season of competition if this participation occurs on or after the 13th month following high school graduation.
  • If a student was already charged a season of intercollegiate competition, they will not also be charged under OCE for the same time period.
  • OCE charges do not mean a loss of amateur status.

Violating Amateurism: When a Student Becomes a Professional

Amateurism violations are a separate matter governed by Article VII of the NAIA Bylaws.
A student loses amateur standing if they engage in any of the following acts, regardless of whether they occurred before or after high school graduation:

  1. Receiving (directly or indirectly) expense reimbursement beyond actual expenses of travel, meals and lodging only. Expenses must be itemized and properly documented.
  2. Signing a contract with any professional team.
  3. Participating in any athletics contest as a professional or as a member of a team where the student in question receives remuneration exceeding the actual expenses of travel, meals and lodging only.
  4. Entering into an agreement of any kind to compete in professional athletics with a professional sports organization.

Once a student violates amateur status, they must go through the amateur reinstatement process, which includes:

  • Submission of documentation to the NAIA Eligibility Center.
  • A season of competition charged for each 12-month period of violation.
  • Residency at the NAIA institution before competing again.

Common Scenarios
SituationRule AppliedSeason Charged?Amateur Status Lost?
Competing with a professional team 14 months after HS graduationOCEYesPending Amateurism Review
Signing a professional contract before collegeAmateurismYes (via reinstatement)Yes
Playing in a semi-pro league that doesn’t pay athletesOCETBDPending Amateurism Review
Receiving prize money above expensesAmateurismYesYes


Key Takeaways
  • OCE = Competition level → May result in a season-of-competition charge.
  • Amateurism = Student’s conduct → May result in loss of amateur status and need for reinstatement.
  • A student can be charged under OCE without losing amateurism, but cannot violate amateurism without a reinstatement process.